It seems I am a little behind in seeing the throwdown episode with Lavain Bakery. I caught it last weekend and like many others I had to find a copycat recipe. I first tried Judy's at http://judyskitchen.blogspot.com/ . They were very good. I haven't had one from the Levain Bakery so I can't do a true comparison, but I liked the concept of having a thick and chewy cookie.
I also tried Bobby's recipe from the show. Although still good, it looked sad in comparison, so flat and more crispy. I also made smaller versions of the Levain recipe...
So, then I thougth I could beef up Bobby's recipe to get a thicker cookie and make it look more like the Levain. It turned out all right. It had a more crackly top. I did change his in respect to the sugars. I switched the amounts of white sugar to brown sugar. I also added about 1/2 cup more flour to thicken the dough.
So over this past week I did more searching regarding the Lavain recipe. I came upon Su Good Sweets blog...http://www.sugoodsweets.com/blog/2006/04/levain/ . There has been much discussion going on on her site since February when I believe the show Throwdown show first aired. One contributor in particular took the lead on discovery as close of a copycat as possible. Her name is Lisa and she now has her own blog at http://lisamichele.wordpress.com/ . Here you can find the next two recipes I tried, the basic chocolate chip cookie and the dark chocolate peanut butter chip cookie. I did not use walnuts in any of my attempts, but I did use pecans in some of the cookies. I really enjoy the toasted pecans with the chocolate. Also, instead of peanut butter chips in the chocolate cookies I used mini Reese's peanut butter cups (chips).
I actually weighed the dough out to 6 oz to see what a true Levain cookie would look like and it is huge! But it looks awesome. I made smaller ones again (1 tablespoon size) to try. I want to take the bigger ones to work to show everyone and then maybe we can split them.
I just couldn't stop there though. I decided I needed to make about 4 or 5 other recipes, I've lost count now... I had made two of them before but I wanted to do a tast comparison against the Levain copy's. Also, I wanted to mention that I love how the Lavaib Bakery has embraced everyone trying to figure out their recipe that they have linked to the blogs I have mentioned on their own website. http://www.levainbakery.com/cookies/recipes.aspx
I think I've decided I don't have to have a favorite chocolate chip cookie recipe. I just love cookies and will enjoy trying recipes and different takes on this favorite treat of mine.
I've also included this one picture of my second attempt at the pate choux recipe from the daring bakers August challenge. This time I think turned out a little bette than my first. Most of them stayed nice and puffed up. I made Dori's pastry cream again and added a 1/4 teaspoon of almond extract to it, which I think made them even better. I made my chocolate sauce a little thicker this time too.